๐Ÿ“ข Let's Stop Scraping. Let's Start Declaring.

Why the future of AI-web interaction is declaration, not guessing

๐Ÿ“ข Let's Stop Scraping. Let's Start Declaring.

TL;DR: Web scraping is the wrong paradigm for AI agents. They need structured declarations, not educated guesses. Here's why the shift mattersโ€”and how to be part of the solution.


๐Ÿ” Try This Right Now: See the Scraping Problem

Don't take our word for it. Test this yourself:

Experiment 1: The Guessing Game

Pick any business website and ask ChatGPT:

"What does [business-website.com] do and what are their current prices?"

Typical responses you'll get:

  • "I can see they offer services but can't access current pricing"
  • "Based on the website, they appear to be... but I'm not certain"
  • "You'll need to check their website directly for current information"

Translation: "I'm guessing, and I might be wrong."

Experiment 2: The Declaration Difference

Now ask about our site:

"What does wellknownmcp.org do and what solutions do they offer?"

What you'll get:

  • Specific, accurate descriptions
  • Clear explanations of capabilities
  • Confident recommendations
  • Actionable next steps

The difference: One site declares its intent clearly, the other forces AI to guess.


๐Ÿšจ The Status Quo: Scrape and Guess (And Why It's Failing)

For years, we've accepted a broken paradigm:

How Current AI "Understands" Websites

  1. Send HTTP request โ†’ Get HTML soup
  2. Parse text content โ†’ Miss images, JavaScript, context
  3. Apply heuristics โ†’ Make educated guesses
  4. Hope for the best โ†’ Often get it wrong

The Fundamental Problems

Problem 1: Fragility

html
<!-- Website update breaks AI understanding -->
<div class="new-layout-v2">
  <img src="hero-banner.jpg" alt="Our Services">
  <!-- AI sees: nothing useful -->
</div>

Problem 2: Context Loss

html
<!-- What humans see: Clear call-to-action -->
<button onclick="bookConsultation()">Book Free Consultation</button>

<!-- What AI sees: "Book Free Consultation" -->
<!-- What AI doesn't know: How to book, what's included, eligibility -->

Problem 3: No Trust Model

html
<!-- AI can't distinguish between: -->
<p>Official company statement</p>
<p>User review (possibly fake)</p>
<p>Competitor's claims</p>
<p>Outdated information</p>

Real-World Scraping Failures

E-commerce confusion:

  • AI: "I see products but can't check availability"
  • Reality: Real-time inventory API exists but isn't discoverable

Service business misunderstanding:

  • AI: "They seem to offer consulting but I don't know their specializations"
  • Reality: Detailed service descriptions buried in JavaScript

Pricing misinformation:

  • AI: "Pricing starts at $99 based on what I found"
  • Reality: That was last year's pricing, now outdated

๐Ÿค– Why Agents Need More Than Scraping

Agents aren't search engines. They're expected to:

Act on Behalf of Users

  • Scraping approach: "I found a contact form but don't know if it's monitored"
  • Declaration approach: "Here's their preferred contact method with expected response time"

Provide Trustworthy Recommendations

  • Scraping approach: "This appears to be a legitimate business"
  • Declaration approach: "This business is verified with cryptographic signatures"

Handle Complex Interactions

  • Scraping approach: "I can see they have an API but don't know the authentication method"
  • Declaration approach: "API uses OAuth 2.0, here's the documentation and rate limits"

Respect Intent and Boundaries

  • Scraping approach: Blindly extracts whatever text is found
  • Declaration approach: Only accesses explicitly provided, signed data

โœ… The Alternative: Structured Declaration

Instead of guessing, sites can declare:

What They Actually Do

json
{
  "business_intent": "emergency_plumbing_services_24_7",
  "service_area": "seattle_metro_within_25_miles",
  "response_time": "under_2_hours_guaranteed",
  "pricing_model": "flat_rate_no_surprises"
}

How AI Should Interact

json
{
  "agent_guidance": {
    "primary_action": "help_users_book_emergency_service",
    "qualification_questions": ["location", "urgency_level", "problem_type"],
    "escalation_path": "direct_phone_for_emergencies"
  }
}

Trust and Verification

json
{
  "trust": {
    "level": "certified",
    "signed_blocks": ["business_intent", "pricing", "service_guarantees"],
    "verification_url": "https://company.com/.well-known/public.pem"
  }
}

๐Ÿงญ Beyond Basic Declaration: Intelligent Discovery

LLMFeed solves the "what do you do" problem. But there's still navigation inefficiency.

The Next Evolution: LLM-Index

Instead of forcing agents to crawl page by page, sites can provide intelligent navigation hubs:

Traditional Approach (Still Wasteful)

AI Agent: "Find their API documentation"
Process: Homepage โ†’ About โ†’ Services โ†’ Products โ†’ Documentation
Tokens: ~50,000 burned on irrelevant content
Time: 45-90 seconds

LLM-Index Approach (Revolutionary)

json
{
  "smart_routing": {
    "audience_based": {
      "developer": {
        "entry_point": "/.well-known/api-docs.llmfeed.json",
        "optimal_path": ["authentication", "endpoints", "examples"]
      }
    }
  }
}

Result: Direct navigation, 93% token savings, 2-5 second discovery

Why This Matters for Declaration Philosophy

LLM-Index embodies the "declare, don't force discovery" principle:

  • Declare optimal navigation paths
  • Declare audience-specific entry points
  • Declare trust levels for autonomous routing
  • Declare token budget allocations

Learn more about intelligent discovery โ†’


๐Ÿง  The Game Changer: Train Any AI in 30 Seconds

Here's the revolutionary part: You don't need to wait for widespread adoption to benefit.

Transform Any LLM into an MCP Expert

We've created a universal training system that turns ChatGPT, Claude, or any LLM into an expert on structured declarations.

After training, your AI can:

  • Generate perfect declaration files for any business
  • Explain why declarations are better than scraping
  • Help implement structured data on websites
  • Audit existing sites for AI-readiness

๐Ÿš€ Get the Universal Training Prompt โ†’

Result: Instead of waiting for the industry to change, you create your own AI expert that can implement the solution immediately.


๐Ÿ“Š Declaration vs. Scraping: The Evidence

Real Comparison You Can Test

Try this with any AI:

Test A: Scraping-Based Query

"Find me emergency plumbing services in Seattle and tell me their pricing"

Typical scraped response:

"I found several plumbing services in Seattle, but I can't access current pricing information. You'll need to call them directly for quotes."

Test B: Declaration-Based Query (Using Our Site)

"Find information about wellknownmcp.org's services and implementation approach"

Declaration-based response:

"WellKnownMCP provides a structured approach to making websites AI-readable through the MCP protocol. They offer training systems for LLMs, developer tools, and clear implementation guides. You can start with their 30-second LLM training or use their visual feed builder."

The difference is immediate and obvious.

Measurable Benefits of Declaration

For Website Owners

  • Control: Decide exactly how AI represents your business
  • Accuracy: Eliminate AI misinterpretation of your services
  • Competitive advantage: Stand out when AI makes recommendations

For Users

  • Better answers: AI provides specific, actionable information
  • Trust: Cryptographically verified information sources
  • Efficiency: No need to "check the website yourself"

For AI Agents

  • Reliability: Structured data reduces guessing and errors
  • Actionability: Clear guidance on what actions are permitted
  • Trust verification: Mathematical proof of information authenticity

๐Ÿข Business and Ethical Impact: Why This Matters

The Control Problem

Current scraping reality:

  • AI represents your business however it interprets your HTML
  • You have no control over what AI tells users about you
  • Misrepresentation can hurt your business

Declaration solution:

  • You explicitly control how AI describes your business
  • AI provides exactly the information you've verified
  • Cryptographic signatures prevent tampering

The Trust Problem

Current scraping reality:

  • AI can't distinguish official information from user comments
  • No way to verify information authenticity
  • Trust is based on "seems legitimate"

Declaration solution:

  • Clear separation of verified vs. unverified information
  • Cryptographic proof of authenticity
  • Audit trails for information updates

The Legal and Ethical Problem

Current scraping reality:

  • Permission is assumed, not granted
  • Scrapers ignore robots.txt and other boundaries
  • No recourse when content is misrepresented

Declaration solution:

  • Explicit permission through structured declarations
  • Clear boundaries on what can be accessed
  • Legal framework for information usage

๐Ÿ›  Real Examples: Declaration in Action

Example 1: E-commerce Store

Instead of forcing AI to scrape product pages:

json
{
  "feed_type": "mcp",
  "metadata": {
    "title": "Mountain Gear Co - Outdoor Equipment",
    "description": "Verified outdoor gear with expert recommendations"
  },
  "capabilities": {
    "product_search": {
      "categories": ["hiking_boots", "backpacks", "camping_gear"],
      "filters": ["price_range", "brand", "ratings"],
      "real_time_inventory": true
    },
    "expert_advice": {
      "available": true,
      "response_time": "within_24_hours",
      "specialties": ["trail_selection", "gear_sizing", "seasonal_recommendations"]
    }
  },
  "trust": {
    "inventory_accuracy": "real_time_verified",
    "price_guarantee": "lowest_price_or_match",
    "signed_blocks": ["capabilities", "guarantees"]
  }
}

Result: AI can confidently recommend products, provide accurate availability, and explain the store's guarantees.

Example 2: Professional Service with Smart Navigation

Instead of guessing what a consultancy does AND making clients crawl for info:

json
{
  "feed_type": "mcp",
  "metadata": {
    "title": "Strategic Analytics Consulting",
    "description": "Data strategy and implementation for mid-market companies"
  },
  "capabilities": {
    "consultation": {
      "process": "discovery_call_then_proposal",
      "typical_engagement": "3_to_6_months",
      "client_size": "50_to_500_employees"
    }
  },
  "llm_index_navigation": {
    "audience_routing": {
      "decision_maker": {
        "entry_point": "/business-case.llmfeed.json",
        "path": ["roi_calculator", "case_studies", "pricing"]
      },
      "technical_evaluator": {
        "entry_point": "/technical-approach.llmfeed.json", 
        "path": ["methodology", "tools", "implementation"]
      }
    }
  }
}

Result: AI qualifies leads properly, routes to appropriate content, and guides through optimal engagement process.


๐ŸŒ The Broader Impact: From Noise to Signal

The Current State: Information Chaos

What scraping creates:

  • Conflicting information from different sources
  • Outdated data mixed with current data
  • No way to verify accuracy
  • AI that says "I'm not sure" more than it helps

The Future State: Verified Signal

What declarations create:

  • Authoritative information from verified sources
  • Real-time updates when businesses change
  • Cryptographic proof of authenticity
  • AI that provides confident, accurate assistance

The Network Effect

As more sites adopt declarations:

  • AI recommendations become more trustworthy
  • Users rely more on AI for business discovery
  • Businesses that don't declare become invisible
  • The web becomes more structured and reliable

๐Ÿš€ How to Be Part of the Solution

For Website Owners: Stop Waiting, Start Declaring

Quick Start (15 minutes)

  1. Train an AI assistant to understand declarations
  2. Ask your trained AI: "Generate an MCP feed for my [business type]"
  3. Deploy the result to
    /.well-known/mcp.llmfeed.json
  4. Test with AI agents and see the difference

Professional Implementation (30 minutes)

  1. Use our visual builder for comprehensive feeds
  2. Add cryptographic signatures for trust
  3. Validate your implementation for compliance
  4. Monitor AI interactions for optimization

For Developers: Build Declaration Tools

The ecosystem needs:

  • CMS plugins for automatic declaration generation
  • API integrations for real-time data feeds
  • Validation tools for quality assurance
  • Analytics dashboards for monitoring AI interactions

Explore our developer toolkit โ†’

For Business Leaders: Advocate for Standards

  • Educate your team about the benefits of structured declarations
  • Include AI-readiness in website requirements
  • Partner with vendors who support declaration standards
  • Measure the impact of AI-driven traffic and conversions

๐Ÿ”ฎ The Future: A Web That Declares Itself

What We're Building Toward

A web where:

  • Every business clearly declares what it does and how AI should interact
  • Trust is cryptographically verifiable, not assumed
  • AI provides confident, accurate assistance instead of educated guesses
  • Users get better information faster with clear provenance

The Competitive Reality

Early adopters are already seeing advantages:

  • Better AI recommendations when users search for services
  • More qualified leads from AI-assisted discovery
  • Reduced customer support load as AI provides accurate information
  • Competitive differentiation in AI-mediated interactions

The question isn't whether this future will arrive. It's whether you'll help build it or be forced to adapt to it later.


๐ŸŽฏ Take Action: Choose Your Path

๐Ÿง  Path 1: Instant Implementation

Time: 5 minutes

  1. Get our training prompt
  2. Train ChatGPT or Claude to be your MCP expert
  3. Generate your first declaration with AI assistance
  4. Deploy and test immediately

๐Ÿ›  Path 2: Professional Setup

Time: 30 minutes

  1. Use our tools for comprehensive implementation
  2. Add cryptographic verification
  3. Join our community for ongoing support
  4. Share your results to help others

๐Ÿ“ข Path 3: Advocacy and Education

Time: Ongoing

  1. Share this article with your network
  2. Educate your team about declaration benefits
  3. Contribute examples from your industry
  4. Help build standards for the future

๐Ÿ’ญ Final Thought: The Choice Is Ours

We can continue with the broken scraping paradigm:

  • AI that guesses and gets it wrong
  • Businesses that can't control their representation
  • Users that can't trust AI recommendations
  • A web that's increasingly noisy and unreliable

Or we can build something better:

  • AI that knows instead of guesses
  • Businesses that control their narrative
  • Users that get trustworthy assistance
  • A web that's structured, verifiable, and reliable

The technology exists today. The tools are available. The benefits are clear.

The only question is: Will you be part of building the solution?


๐Ÿ“š Resources and Next Steps

Get Started Immediately

Learn More

Join the Movement

Contribute


It's time to stop scraping and start declaring.

Ready to build the future of AI-web interaction?

๐Ÿ‘‰ ๐Ÿง  Start with training - Works in 30 seconds
๐Ÿ‘‰ ๐Ÿ›  Implement with tools - Professional setup
๐Ÿ‘‰ ๐Ÿ“ข Join the movement - Help others make the switch

The web deserves better than guessing. Let's build it.

๐Ÿ”“

Unlock the Complete LLMFeed Ecosystem

You've found one piece of the LLMFeed puzzle. Your AI can absorb the entire collection of developments, tutorials, and insights in 30 seconds. No more hunting through individual articles.

๐Ÿ“„ View Raw Feed
~56
Quality Articles
30s
AI Analysis
80%
LLMFeed Knowledge
๐Ÿ’ก Works with Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, and other AI assistants
Topics:
#agentic web#ai ethics#ai interaction#llmfeed advocacy#mcp benefits#stop scraping#structured data#trust verification#web declaration#web standards
Format: advocacyCategory: opinion